Customer service call evaluation template
For QA reviewers assessing an inbound support conversation: from understanding the issue to explaining a fix, confirming the outcome and owning remaining actions.
Evaluate the process you actually handle
Make the rules yours
Configure the supplied rules and applicability gates against your approved SOP. A missing reference is an evidence gap, not a reason to exclude an applicable check.
Record what happened
Each row holds applicability, result and evidence or an exclusion reason. Call ID, reviewer, scope and SOP version keep the assessment interpretable.
Keep the score honest
Completion is unweighted: applicable checks met / applicable checks. It measures these checks, not business quality, conversion likelihood or a universal pass.
Use the workbook in five steps
- Read Instructions, then duplicate Scorecard for each call.
- Set your SOP version, reviewer, call ID and scope. Review each rule and its applicability gate.
- Choose Applies Yes, No or Unknown. A No needs a genuine context-based N/A reason.
- For applicable checks, select Met, Not met or Unknown and cite evidence. Configure critical flags only where your SOP establishes them.
- Resolve unknown, blank, invalid or evidence-missing rows before using a completed percentage. Inspect critical findings separately.
These formulas cover the fixed 15 rows. Changing the rule text is supported; adding checks requires extending and revalidating the formulas. Met requires every applicable element of a rule; an assessable required omission is Not met. Configure the condition list to the selected process or offer. There is no default pass threshold.
All 15 checks, with their applicability gates
Opening
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Greeting | Use a courteous greeting when the opening is available. | Opening present. |
| Agent name | State your own name, unless already explicitly established in a supplied continuation. | New opening or identity not established. |
| Brand name | State the organisation represented, unless already explicitly established in supplied context. | Brand not already established. |
Access
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Customer verification | Complete the identity check required by your SOP before account-specific disclosure. | Account-specific information requested; configure approved verification rule. |
Understanding
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Issue confirmation | Restate the problem and obtain confirmation before selecting an action. | Meaningful issue discussion. |
Handling
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant clarification | Ask for the missing fact needed to select the next troubleshooting or service action. | A relevant fact is missing. |
| Accurate response | Give an answer consistent with the supplied policy or knowledge reference. | An answer is provided. Missing approved reference means Unknown, not N/A. |
| Action explanation | Explain the proposed fix or service action in clear steps. | A fix or action is proposed. |
| Hold permission | Ask before putting the customer on hold. | Hold used. |
| Escalation handoff | Explain the receiving team and reason when escalating. | Escalation or transfer occurs. |
Resolution
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Outcome confirmation | Ask whether the proposed action resolved the stated issue. | Resolution is attempted and customer can assess it. |
| Remaining action owner | Name who owns any remaining action. | Further action remains. |
| Remaining action timing | State the agreed time or time window for the remaining action. | Further action remains; SOP requires a timeframe. |
Closing
| Check | Observable rule | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Closing summary | Summarise the resolution or outstanding plan before a normal close. | Normal closure opportunity. |
| Courteous farewell | Thank the customer or use a courteous farewell. | Normal closure opportunity. |
A fictional completed example
Fictional call DEMO-S001 · SOP SUPPORT-DEMO-v1
REF-S1: payment posting can take two working days. SUPPORT-DEMO-v1 requires identity verification before account disclosure and a timeframe for follow-up.
| Check | Applies? | Result | Evidence / exclusion reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greeting | Yes | Met | Agent: Good morning, how can I help? |
| Agent name | Yes | Met | Agent: My name is Mira. |
| Brand name | Yes | Met | Agent: You have reached DemoCo Support. |
| Customer verification | Yes | Not met · critical | Agent discusses the account balance before performing the identity check required by fictional SOP SUPPORT-DEMO-v1. |
| Issue confirmation | Yes | Met | Agent restates that the payment is missing; customer confirms this is the issue. |
| Relevant clarification | No | N/A | Customer supplied payment date and reference at the start; no fact needed for the next action is missing. |
| Accurate response | Yes | Met | Agent says posting can take two working days, matching supplied fictional policy REF-S1. |
| Action explanation | Yes | Met | Agent explains how to refresh the ledger, then explains a trace request if the payment is still missing. |
| Hold permission | No | N/A | No hold occurs in the complete fictional call. |
| Escalation handoff | No | N/A | No transfer or escalation occurs in the complete fictional call. |
| Outcome confirmation | Yes | Met | Agent asks whether the payment now appears; customer says it does not. |
| Remaining action owner | Yes | Met | Agent names the payments desk as owner of the trace request. |
| Remaining action timing | Yes | Not met | Agent promises a trace update but gives no time window although fictional SOP requires one. |
| Closing summary | Yes | Met | Agent summarises the missing payment and the payments desk trace request. |
| Courteous farewell | Yes | Met | Agent: Thank you for calling. Goodbye. |
1 critical failure; 0 unresolved critical checks. This is a fictional SOP illustration. Completion does not override critical findings or establish a universal pass.
Missing evidence must remain visible
If audio is truncated before an opening or close, use Unknown for the hidden check. If an answer or price was given but the approved reference is missing, accuracy is Unknown, not N/A. A supplied continuation that explicitly establishes identity may legitimately exclude a repeated introduction.
N/A requires Applies No plus a reason. Contradictory values, invalid pasted entries, unknown or blank applicable rows and missing evidence withhold the completed percentage. All N/A means no applicable checks. Critical failures and unresolved critical checks stay separate from completion.
Choose the right review scope
This is a support-resolution rubric, not an upsell checklist.
For another process, see the inbound sales call evaluation template. If you need analysis configured around your own SOP, explore SOP call auditing or prepare an enquiry draft.